How do you identify real vintage Roseville pottery?
Is this mark missing anything?
![URL removed]
wallyh Reputation: 387 See wallyh's booth |
I stay away from Roseville based on the amount of reproductions out there and not having a great knowledge of this potter. The “R” doesn’t look right. Also the only thing I do know is original pieces are much heavier than the reproductions that use white clay that is much lighter and chips easier.
and then to offer a little info I [URL removed]
One of the best potteries in the whole world is produced by Roseville potteries. These potteries are not only artistic, but they are also colorful, beautiful, and special. The vintage Roseville pottery that you can purchase today can be dated back to the middle of 1800’s to 1900’s. These potteries are definitely epitome of true beauty.
Because of the popularity of the vintage Roseville pottery, there are a lot of people who have been producing fake designs and imitations and sell it for a large price. Because of these imitations, it can be a challenge for those who are eying to buy a Roseville pottery. To be able to determine whether the pottery is authentic or not is very important because if you don’t know the difference between an original and an imitation, you might just waste your money buying an imitation.
In purchasing an antique pottery by Roseville, you should check on the initials present on the bottom of the pottery. The oldest potteries by Roseville have these initials at the bottom of their potteries. Usually, these initials would represent the name of the artist who made the pottery. Aside from that, if the pottery also contains the “Rv†stamp at the bottom, this also means that the pottery is original. Another identifier for the originality of the product is the label at the bottom which either state “Pinecone†or “Rosevilleâ€. Usually, fake potteries would contain “Roseville USA†on the bottom. If you saw this label on the bottom, then you should consider looking for other items because this one is a fake.
Aside from the stamp, you should also carefully analyze the colors of the pottery that you are going to purchase. Usually, the original vintage Roseville pottery would have a combination of the light and the dark colors. On the other hand, those fake potteries are often colored brown, light blue, patterns of pink, and lime green. However, these colors are also used for original potteries but not that often.
Determining originality of the product based from the colors can be a little difficult especially for those who are not very much familiar with these antique potteries. However, you can also check the design or the decoration. In the original, the decors and the design are sophisticated and very detailed, while on the other hand, those fake imitations have sloppy and amateurish designs. True enough, it is difficult to imitate a work of art that is carefully crafted.
Another important determining factor to check on the authenticity of the pottery that you are going to purchase would be the “R†shape on the bottom label. In the fake potteries, the “R†is weirdly shaped and very inconsistent and if you compare it with the genuine pottery, you will see a big difference between the two. This letter “R†can be a great identifier especially for those who already owned numerous pieces from Roseville pottery. They can easily identify whether the pottery is authentic or just an imitation.
You can also check the authenticity of the pottery by feeling the glaze on the pottery. On the imitation, the glaze would feel rough and unfinished. On the other hand, the authentic pottery by Roseville would feel smooth.
Prior to starting on a collection of these potteries by Roseville, it would be best to have a good background about it first before buying or you might end up buying fake items.
sofyblu2 Reputation: 63 See sofyblu2's booth |
Hello Wallyh, This will help you with the task of identifying fake Roseville pottery. Remember, Mark, Color, Detail, and Weight.
[URL removed]
Fathertime Reputation: 358 See Fathertime's booth |
Edited to remove information. If you want the link I had posted, contact me through my booth. Thanks!
MNblarneystone Reputation: 88 See MNblarneystone's booth |
The base color is wrong, JMO. Also, U.S.A. is missing!
AllThingsVintage44 Reputation: 28 See AllThingsVintage44's booth |
I don’t know, but I’m gonna be watching this with interest—c’mon, let’s hear more from folks who know Roseville!
loneelk Reputation: 128 See loneelk's booth |
Morning Wally!
Here you go. This for anyone that needs info on Rosville.
[URL removed]
![URL removed]
![URL removed]
The pictured Rosville is mine.
gypsygirl Reputation: 32 See gypsygirl's booth |
i have sold pottery for 25 year. i have a great book on roseville. if you want i can xerox some information and sent it to you. kelly
vintagegirlcat Reputation: 12 See vintagegirlcat's booth |
I know how to identify vintage Roseville pottery, but I’m always open to new tricks. Great comments so far on how you go about it… :)
wallyh Reputation: 387 See wallyh's booth |
Thanks for the great question! I’m learning so much on here. :D
BookbinEtc Reputation: 1320 See BookbinEtc's booth |
Viewed: 8070 times
Asked: almost 14 years ago
Latest response: almost 14 years ago
Remember these tips:
- Use links to other sources to support your opinions
- Use examples where possible
- Put yourself in the inquirers shoes: what extra info would be helpful?
Should I post a comment or an answer?
You can only post one answer, so make it count. Maybe your reply is more fitting as a comment instead?
Post an answer for:
- Replies that directly and specifically answer the original question
Post a comment for:
- "Thanks," "Me too," "I agree," or "Works for me" types of replies
- When you would like the original poster to provide more details
- When you have more to add to someone else's question or answer
See also our Roundtable FAQ.
Formatting
Community help posts follow certain formatting guidelines, which may impact the look of your post. If you're interested in tweaking the format, instructions are available here.